How not shuffling the deck theoretically is more magical - Page 2

TommySteal · 05-20-2011, 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by la0o9

card melts through the deck= Shifty card rise( search for it)/ a rising card gimmick or ACR routine?

The last part of my initial post was just referring to an ACR. But as for the debate, yes, not shuffling in an ACR would theoretically be more magical.

---------- Post added at 08:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:28 AM ----------

But kind of boring

TheMisdirectingHand · 05-20-2011, 02:50 PM

The whole point of the ACR is to show how ambitious the card is in the process of jumping to the top. It would seem weird if we just started shuffling every time the card was lost. If we WERE shuffling in an ACR, it would not be magical at all. That would just be demonstrating your ability to control cards, rather than the card controlling itself.

la0o9 · 05-20-2011, 05:11 PM

hmmm, actually, it WOULD be very interesting to use this type of material in a routine, i just thought of some good stuffs( quick question, if you guys were audience, would you like things to just happen without you noticing at first no matter how hard you try to notice it, or would you find mentally depriving visual tricks better?

Albert · 05-20-2011, 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by la0o9

hmmm, actually, it WOULD be very interesting to use this type of material in a routine, i just thought of some good stuffs( quick question, if you guys were audience, would you like things to just happen without you noticing at first no matter how hard you try to notice it, or would you find mentally depriving visual tricks better?

As an adult, I like mentally challenging tricks better because older people tend to know more about the possibility of gimmicks. If something doesn't scientifically make sense, I would probably be more amazed. On the other hand, depending on how visual and in what context this visual magic happens, this could also fall in the category of being "mentally inexplicable".

If I was younger, I would probably prefer visual tricks; younger people are just like that

TommySteal · 05-20-2011, 09:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheMisdirectingHand

The whole point of the ACR is to show how ambitious the card is in the process of jumping to the top. It would seem weird if we just started shuffling every time the card was lost. If we WERE shuffling in an ACR, it would not be magical at all. That would just be demonstrating your ability to control cards, rather than the card controlling itself.

I think you miss my point David. No magician in their right mind would shuffle the deck EVERY time the card was lost, but for a good routine to be interesting and entertaining there has to be variety in method to how the effect is achieved otherwise spectators would get bored. What I mean is if you fairly show the card being inserted into the deck, and without the use of duplicate that card then jumps to the top, that's the trick over , no routine - that's real magic.

Kieran Oloughlin · 05-21-2011, 09:07 AM

Or fallen by dg

MarkoViner · 05-21-2011, 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Albert

As an adult, I like mentally challenging tricks better because older people tend to know more about the possibility of gimmicks. If something doesn't scientifically make sense, I would probably be more amazed. On the other hand, depending on how visual and in what context this visual magic happens, this could also fall in the category of being "mentally inexplicable".

If I was younger, I would probably prefer visual tricks; younger people are just like that

Yes I have to agree with you. I have noticed that about the spectators too

05-20-2011, 02:50 PM	#22
TheMisdirectingHand David Nguyen Join Date: Aug 2010 Location: Rosemead, California Posts: 406	The whole point of the ACR is to show how ambitious the card is in the process of jumping to the top. It would seem weird if we just started shuffling every time the card was lost. If we WERE shuffling in an ACR, it would not be magical at all. That would just be demonstrating your ability to control cards, rather than the card controlling itself. __________________ "There are three types of people in this world; •People who talk and never do: The Lower Class •People who talk and do at the same time: The Middle Class •People who do before they ever talk: The Upper Class A real man does not need to talk. We are the upper class." -Joseph Lau

05-20-2011, 05:11 PM	#23
la0o9 Move monkey atm Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: Not where you'd want to go :P Posts: 747	hmmm, actually, it WOULD be very interesting to use this type of material in a routine, i just thought of some good stuffs( quick question, if you guys were audience, would you like things to just happen without you noticing at first no matter how hard you try to notice it, or would you find mentally depriving visual tricks better? __________________ "Doubt isn't the same as saying people are bad, it simply means you actually care, 100% trust is nothing more than ignorance"~ Akiyama Shinichi- Liar Game "It's not the destination but the road to it that is worth the trip" "Be careful what you wish for... it might just come true"~ old saying "It's a small world, but only relatively" "Reality is not the world, it is the way humankind depicts the world, thus when you alter a person's way of seeing the world, you alter reality itself"

05-21-2011, 09:07 AM	#26
Kieran Oloughlin Join Date: Jan 2011 Location: Australia Posts: 414	Or fallen by dg